Sunlit contemporary Arcadia living room with an ivory sofa, pale stone fireplace and a window overlooking a citrus garden.

Should You List Your Arcadia Home in December or Wait for January?

"Any reading below 90 means the market favors buyers, and 69.9 is signaling that buyers are seizing control." The Cromford Report wrote that after its Cromford Market Index for all of Greater Phoenix fell to 69.9 on October 21, its lowest reading since March 12, 2009. If you own a home in Arcadia and plan to sell this winter, that reading sharpens a question every owner faces around Thanksgiving: launch in December, or wait for the January season everyone talks about?

The usual advice is to wait, since buyers come back after the holidays. The last two winters in Phoenix ZIP 85018 don't back that up. January did bring more buyers. It brought far more sellers. In both winters, a home listed in December faced the least competition per accepted offer of any winter month, and the ratio got sharply worse in January.

What January Added in 85018

Phoenix REALTORS publishes a monthly Local Market Update for each ZIP code, built on ARMLS data. The single-family figures for 85018 show the same pattern in back-to-back years. In December 2024, 32 homes were newly listed and 29 went under contract. In January 2025, 99 homes were newly listed and 41 went under contract. New listings roughly tripled from one month to the next. Accepted offers rose by about 40 percent.

The following winter repeated the pattern on a smaller scale. According to the December 2025 report for 85018, 36 homes came to market that month and 22 went under contract. The January 2026 report shows 77 new listings and 28 pending sales. February 2026 continued the trend, with 57 new listings and only 16 pending sales.

One way to read these numbers is to count accepted offers for every ten homes that came to market in the same month:

Month New listings, 85018 Pending sales, 85018 Pendings per 10 new listings
December 2024 32 29 about 9
January 2025 99 41 about 4
December 2025 36 22 about 6
January 2026 77 28 under 4
February 2026 57 16 under 3

The pending sales in a given month are not offers on that month's new listings. Many go to homes listed earlier. The ratio still shows the balance a fresh listing walks into. In December, it shares the spotlight with a small group of other new listings while buyers are still signing contracts. In January, it arrives alongside two or three times as many new listings, and the number of signed contracts barely changes.

The total supply shows the same thing. Single-family inventory in 85018 stood at 177 homes in November 2025, fell to 140 in December, climbed to 179 in January 2026, and reached 203 by February. A buyer shopping 85018 in December 2025 had the smallest set of homes to choose from of any month that winter.

What a December Launch Gives Up

December has real costs, and the same reports show them. Fewer homes went under contract in December 2025 than in January 2026, 22 against 28, so the December buyer pool is smaller in absolute terms. Homes that closed in December 2025 also sold for 95.3 percent of list price, compared with 96.4 percent for January 2026 closings and 96.7 percent in February. On a $1.5 million home, the gap between 95.3 and 96.4 percent is about $16,500.

Read that price figure with care. It describes homes that closed in December, which is a different group from the homes that were listed in December. Days on market until sale works the same way: 85 for homes that closed in December 2025, 70 for January and 79 for February. None of the three tells you how a listing launched in a given month performed.

The honest summary is that December gives a seller fewer buyers but far less fresh competition for their attention. January gives a seller more buyers and a crowd of new listings, many of which went to market for the same reason: they were waiting for January. In 85018 over the last two winters, the crowd grew faster than the buyer pool.

These are small samples. A single month in one ZIP comes down to a few dozen transactions, and the Phoenix REALTORS October 2026 report for 85018 notes that percent changes "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." Two winters set a pattern worth planning around. They are not a law of the market.

This Winter Starts From a Heavier Position

The January rush matters more this year because 85018 is heading into the holidays with more supply and fewer contracts than it had a year ago. In October 2026, the ZIP had 76 new single-family listings against 63 in October 2025. Pending sales fell to 18 from 30, and inventory rose to 199 homes from 183. Homes that closed in October 2026 sold for 95.9 percent of list price, down from 96.9 percent a year earlier.

Not every October number is soft. Closed sales nearly doubled, from 27 to 49, and the median sale price rose to $2,113,500 from $1,620,000 over the same twelve months. A median for a single month depends on which homes happened to close. The pending count is the more current signal, and it points toward fewer buyers signing now.

The metro trend is the same. In the ARMLS Monthly Indicators for October 2026, single-family pending sales across Greater Phoenix fell 45.9 percent from October 2025, to 2,775 from 5,127, while single-family inventory rose 10.6 percent to 23,044 homes. The Cromford Report's early November summary calls the market "clearly weaker than it was a month ago" and puts the contract ratio at its lowest level since February 2009.

The metro data also shows the December gap at a much larger scale. Across Greater Phoenix, 4,939 single-family homes were newly listed in December 2025, and 8,801 followed in January 2026. Pending sales went from 3,867 to 5,422 over the same two months. So the pattern holds across the Valley, and it was sharper in 85018.

Put the two years together. If January 2027 looks like the last two Januaries, an Arcadia seller who waits will list into a market that already had 199 homes for sale in October, with a new wave of listings arriving at the same time. A December listing would compete with the smaller group of owners willing to show a home over the holidays.

What a December Launch Asks of You

Choosing December is mostly a scheduling question, and the schedule is tighter than it seems from Thanksgiving week. A December listing in 85018 enters a smaller market, with 36 new single-family listings in December 2025, so each one stays in front of active buyers longer. That is an advantage only if the home is ready on day one. Repairs, staging, photography and the listing story need to be finished before launch. A home that goes live half-prepared in December gives away the reason for listing then.

Pricing works the same way. In a market Cromford describes as favoring buyers, the asking price should be set against recent closed sales of comparable Arcadia homes. The 199 homes in inventory show what owners are asking, and closed sales show what buyers have paid. Our home valuation page is a starting point for that comparison, and our approach for sellers shows how we organize the work that comes before a listing goes live.

Waiting for January is still a reasonable choice for some homes. If a property needs more than a few weeks of preparation, a well-prepared January listing will do better than a rushed December one. Owners who host family through the holidays, or whose homes don't show well under a full calendar, may also be better off waiting. In both of the last two winters, January's surge of new listings arrived on schedule, and a seller who expects it can plan around it.

For neighborhood context beyond the numbers, our Arcadia neighborhood page covers the area itself.

If you're weighing a December launch against January, Vanessa Roark can tell you whether your home can realistically be photo-ready, staged and priced from closed comps in time to list before the January rush, with the repairs and staging project-managed for you. Book a complimentary Home Marketing & Strategy Session.

Let's Find Your Dream Home

I can help you determine a property's value, make a competitive offer, handle contracts, and more. I'll guide you through every step of the home-buying process.

Follow Me on Instagram